Originally Posted by
Thunderroad
As an update/DP, but first...
If you have trouble getting through to a person at the Reconsideration line, in this thread I summarize how I was able to do it pretty easily:
No More Chase Reconsideration Line?
As for the update:
I'd applied last month just before the 200K deadline, then received a letter a week later explaining that I'd been turned down because of too many recent credit card applications (which, as I'll explain below, was a 5/24 referende), an insufficient business structure (which I suppose meant I was applying as a sole proprietor) and an insufficient business deposit relationship with Chase (?).
I thought I'd give the reconsideration line a try. After I (pretty quickly) got through to a someone, she fixed on the fact that I was (inadvertently) over 5/24. She even went down the list of the banks from whom I'd gotten six cards (!) within the past 24 months, and the months I'd gotten them.
FWIW, I messed up because: 1) I mistakenly thought the earliest card fell outside the 5/24 window and 2) I'd also mistakenly thought (though I had known but forgotten about this) that a Cap One business card counted as a personal card for 5/24 purposes.
So, my bad. I didn't ask whether the other two reasons would have disqualified me anyway, though the fact that she quickly focused on the 5/24 factor made me think that perhaps that was the main obstacle.
thank u for the update.
wat were ur stats going in? new accnts + HP? 2/6 - x/12 - 6/24?
and sounds like u have 2 INKs open? do u put spend on them?
IMHO u were a victim of unfortunate algo denial. chase must have changed some rules recently. cuz all ur rejection reasons are "legit" and used in the past but very weak and YMMV. not applied consistently but all applied to you.
- 5/24? plenty of pple getting approved at 6/24 and even 7/24. CSRB has been a unique case.
- biz structure? yes, LLCs have seen better approval odds but not guaranteed.
- biz depo? again. biz checking have seen better approval odds but not guaranteed.
the last 2 denial reasons are weak fillers. so it makes sense the agent didnt focus on that. but they also have old training of 5/24 so they just focused on that even tho its not consistently applied.
there has been very clear DPs showing way more flexibility w/ approval criteria for the new CSR biz vs INKs.
and before the INK train went under lifetime rule, chase made approvals much stricter w/ limits. and it did matter how many other chase biz cards u had open.
http://www.doctorofcredit.com/report...d-applications
see this DP thread:
http://www.reddit.com/r/churning/com...int_megathread
http://www.reddit.com/r/churning/com...aset_fall_2024
was the denial final, no recon?