Originally Posted by
Mwenenzi
What has positioning fares to HKG got to do with anything? With alliances, subject to the t&c's, you can earn and burn on partners. Status earnings on partners can be more difficult.
I'm a little puzzled there too about positioning flights since all OW airlines in the region fly to SGN. But perhaps the OP means required segments on that airline to acquire status? JL requires 50% of status points earned to be on JL. CX isn't as rigid but they do have a 2 CX segment requirement to upgrade status in the new program.
Originally Posted by
Travelingjack04
Hello everyone,
I need some help on deciding on if I should go with JAL or Cathay Pacific program for this year. I am based in HCMC have Platinum status with Vietnam Airlines United Gold, and Atmos Gold. I will do four paid long haul paid business class flights this year, mostly economy flights within Asia for short haul. Strictly looking on which would be the best program for my spend. By the end of the year:
At minimum I will have JGC Premier status (10,000 short of Diamond)
I will have Cathay Pacific Gold but not really close to Platinum
It seems like JAL would give me more for how much I am spending for flights (OW emerald vs sapphire). Is there any reason for me to go with Cathay Pacific? The biggest benefit with Cathay is the fact that it's only a 2.5 flight from HCMC and positioning fares would more affordable.
No need to repeat what Mwenenzi has already said, but agree it doesn't sound like you need a new FFP. What is your objective of using JL or CX's programs vs. AS that you already have? Perhaps focus instead of getting OW Emerald with AS?
When doing your calculations, be aware that JL requires 50% of your status points (FOP) be earned on JL flights and their award chart is not competitive. You also mentioned JL Premier status, but there is a disclaimer on the site
*This status is for JAL Global Club members only.
. JGC is primarily for residents of Japan since you have to hold an eligible JAL credit card to enroll. I know there used to be a way for non-residents to join but I no longer see it on the site as an option. (someone else can chime in if it's somewhere else and I'm just missing it).
CX just changed their program, so make sure you're aware that for Gold you have to earn 900 points, not 600 if you're starting from no status since status points reset after upgrading to Silver. This is the same way A3 works in *A. With CX and AS having fairly similar distance based award charts, I don't see the advantage there of switching unless for enhanced award availability on CX.