Hello everyone,

I need some help on deciding on if I should go with JAL or Cathay Pacific program for this year. I am based in HCMC have Platinum status with Vietnam Airlines United Gold, and Atmos Gold. I will do four paid long haul paid business class flights this year, mostly economy flights within Asia for short haul. Strictly looking on which would be the best program for my spend. By the end of the year:

At minimum I will have JGC Premier status (10,000 short of Diamond)
I will have Cathay Pacific Gold but not really close to Platinum

It seems like JAL would give me more for how much I am spending for flights (OW emerald vs sapphire). Is there any reason for me to go with Cathay Pacific? The biggest benefit with Cathay is the fact that it's only a 2.5 flight from HCMC and positioning fares would more affordable.