You don't have to use auto add with CP+ to get an offer added to several cards. I personally very much dislike to do auto add because it clutters up my app with a ton of useless offers that are saved to my card. This is what I do to get specific offers added to all cards they are available on:1. Open the CardPointers extension in Chrome on a desktop or laptop by clicking on the purple button that says " Add Offers with CardPointers" that is right at the top of the Amex offers and benefits section while logged into your Amex account 2. At the bottom of the window there is a drop down. Select "All Cards (CP+)" 3. This will refresh the window to show you a combined list of offers across all your cards in that login. For each offer it will tell you how many of your cards have that offer but not which ones, however that doesn't matter because when you check off an offer you want to add and then hit the purple check mark on the lower right of the window, that offer will get added to all the cards it is found on. In this way I've been able to add only the offers I want across all cards it's available on without having to add every single offer to every single card.