Presuming you mean the RI in Gravenhurst? It is also a very nice property with a resort feel. Many of the amenities that might be included at the JW (water rentals, boat tours, etc.) are available adjacent to the RI on a "pay-as-you-go" basis. There are also a couple of decent restaurants within walking distance. The choice between the two, if cost is not a factor, is entirely up to your needs in the area. Unless upgraded to a suite at the JW, the rooms are comparable. I've never been overwhelmed with the dining at the JW and as a data point, my last stay there only yielded continental breakfast with an up-charge for full menu. OTOH the Residence Inn breakfast is pretty meh, typical of the brand standard. The RI is in a small quaint town whereas the JW is more isolated, so again - personal preference. They're both good hotels.