FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Does D1 meaningfully beat out UA or AA in any category?
Old Jul 5, 2025 | 5:04 am
  #2  
emma dog
Moderator: Delta SkyMiles
2M
50 Countries Visited
All eyes on you!
20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Hotlanta.
Programs: DL (duh), AA 1MM, Bonvoy Titanium, HH Diamond
Posts: 8,566
Originally Posted by mcrw00
Is my read on D1 in line with others’ recent experiences? How do they compare today with UA and AA? I find it hard to believe that the product I describe above can continue to command a 20-70% premium over its direct competitors in the US
I haven’t flown UA or AA business in years, but I have flown BA, AF, SQ, JL, and KAL business class since COVID.

My assessment of DL’s business class hasn’t changed at all. It’s a “fine” product on par with the European airlines but not as good as the Asian carriers. I understand why people would have preferences amongst the various Asian carriers, and I’ll defer on which ones are “best” for this discussion.

I don’t understand the desire for the “suite” as I just don’t have the “need” for privacy like some others. As such, seat comfort is my #1 priority, followed by the food. I don’t care about the IFE too much since I spend most of my flight sleeping or working/web surfing. With that being said, DL’s product on the 359 is great. And the 763 is awful.

I haven’t had food served on one tray except for late night express meals. I don’t drink so couldn’t care less about the “lack of service” discussions, but I haven’t noticed it either. I flew ATL-EDI on Thursday night and the gentleman had two screwdrivers with breakfast, and I was served two rounds of coffee. So I guess I just haven’t noticed it.

re DL V AA and UA? Fly whatever is least expensive and fits your schedule. If you’re in business, why are you loyal??? I mean, I really don’t care that the FA welcomed me and said “Mr Dog, thank you for being a DM. I see you requested no dinner on this flight.” Don’t pay the premium if the alternatives make sense.
emma dog is offline