I must say I am surprised Chase included the $300 travel credit. My random guess is they wanted to axe it, but quickly realized it was a deal-breaker. The 2-night stay on The Edit is a bummer. I doubt I will consistently do that twice per year.
Thankfully, my AF renews in September. So with these things considered, I will likely be keeping the card for a year to see how it works in practice. I think lounge access will still be a wild card for me. I absolutely love the Sapphire lounge. Probably more than I need to. However, if they continue to offer a decent lounge footprint, we will see....