We're looking at a property in Barbados for next winter. The reviews are 3 years old. I'm open to any recommendations for all islands except DR from recent experiences.

My question was moved to this thread which I’ve read through. Our list of “wants” are very much like Outofmyelement. Quiet, nature, history.

Already been to Aruba, St. Kitts, St. Thomas.

Would like weather that’s warmer than Fort Lauderdale in February. Is Puerto Rico warmer?

I wanted to add my $.02 about Scrub Island. I think a great visit is possible but not highly probable. Trapped. The week we went flu ran through the resort, guests and staff.

The property had defects, things were broken, moldy. A common response was parts are hard to get in the island.

Too far, over hyped.