I did a bit of searching and it doesn't seem like there's any comparison article for the Club Personal vs Club Business. Lots of articles about the two business cards though.
For the business card:
+ doesn't count towards 5/24
+ save $75 on AF
- no IHG Platinum but I have IHG card anyway
- no $75 IHG statement credit
- no GE/Precheck/Nexus credit but I have enough of these
- can earn less PQP but this doesn't sound like a good deal anyway
- no 10% on Saver awards
- 2x on UA instead of 4x, but I would use CSR anyway
- SUB: 80k is better than 50k + 1k PQP, no 5k for AU
Most of the negatives seem pretty minor, the Business might be better for me...