Thanks for all the replies. Seems like the St. Regis is the clear winner amongst the group.

For me, having a pool or beach access isn't high on my list of priorities.

Not sure why I didn't consider the Sheraton Grand, what are other's opinions of this property?


For my dates, the JW and Sheraton are similar in pricing, with the StR being a good 30-40% higher. I don't personally mind the extra cost at the StR, but is it "worth" it?


EDIT: Forgot to mention, I will be Bonvoy Plat when staying, so elite recognition will be a factor as well.