You are certainly entitled to your opinion, but I resided in Hong Kong for nearly a decade and practically lived in The Wing and The Pier during many, if not most of those years. This said, I just experienced the same FFD menu shown in your photo roughly a week ago. In terms of food quality, it's wasn't even remotely a close call. Also, the current menu is a massively scaled-down shadow of itself from just two years ago. Although the burger was pretty decent to be fair.

As for your onboard experience, glad you got lucky. But this is clearly more the exception than the rule. Service levels in BA Club World are far superior to AA F most of the time.