Originally Posted by
ani90
This is the main reason I too tend to gravitate to UA for most international travel. Only way round that is to (where possible) buy partner flights through United and that way you have the flexibility and ability to change. That though, generally, restricts you to preferred partners, as non-preferred partners generally overpriced on United, but sometimes can get reasonable fares on non-preferred partners but may have to go through Google flights to get them to show up. Other thing that can work sometimes is to call as may occasionally can get an agreeable agent. Couple weeks ago I bought a BR ticket on 016 with no UA segment over the phone .
This approach though would defeat your objective of maximizing PQP as you end up with spend based PQP, but given the PQP caps, it seems to me that on practical basis, it would be the exception rather than the rule that buying a partner ticket on non 016 stock will lead to substantial increase in PQP per dollar spent - those very cheap premium cabin tickets are largely theoretical (other than a pure PQP run) as they are generally impossible to find for routes and times that one wishes to travel. All the times I have flown partner airlines on non-016 stock in 2023, I ended up with well below 1 PQP per dollar spent, sometimes lower than 0.5.
If traveling on a 016 ticket, I prefer to fly UA metal in Y because of E+, and on many international segments, you get the middle seat empty in E+.
As for non-016 tickets, sometimes you get really good PQP deals on LH, LX, NH and others. One of my favorite routes to harvest PQPs is SFO-CGK on a NH ticket, which could include UA metal from SFO-TYO. For instance, if you book that route in January 2024, for a B fare basis in Y you pay $1800 and get 3000 PQPs. Sometimes you get fares as low as $800 and yet earn nearly 1500 or more PQPs, given NH's preferred status and hence 750 PQP per segment limit. It's a lot of work to look for these deals. But for 2024 I'll spend more time monitoring the Premium fare section of FT. When you buy cheap non-016 business class tickets they can yield good returns too.