Movie Review Forums
Book Review Forums
Favourite Salad Dressing Forum
Best brand of electric toaster Forum
High heel shoes user rating Forum
Best lawn-mover forum
Beers Of The World rating Forum
They all exist
somewhere on the web I feel sure. And work well THERE.
And none have anything to do with miles and points as far as I can see. 
FT cannot be all things to all people surely. There does need to be a line drawn somewhere, and for 5 years
Randy seemed to have the mix pretty much perfect.