USA driver rented car in Canada and hit my car in NY. Police Report puts him at 100% blame and that he made an illegal turn.
The driver has no private car insurance, was legally allowed to rent a car, but not legally allowed to cross into USA, as he is 24 and rental company specifies that renter must be => 25 in order to cross the border to USA.
Driver has US license, not Canadian.

With whom do I make a claim?
Is the rental car company (Enterprise) liable?