Back to that Shell with the Wayne Pumps/Verifone POS/working EMV Contactless at pump.
Tapped debit card. No PIN prompt and went through as card type credit using generic issuer AID.
Tried mobile wallet with a credit card. Receipt has the "verified by PIN" line on it so they are using the device verification.
Also this time it asked if I wanted to use Fuel Rewards each time.
Looking forward to Contactless becoming the standard at gas stations. Maybe they can get rid of the clunky card readers in the pumps completely.