Originally Posted by
JMN57
You do (or at least should). Driving back-and-forth Sicily for a day trip isn't my idea of fun (and I don't have an infant). See the post above - all of those are more accessible to Catania.
Personally, I think Ortigia is fantastic. Great historical (ancient) architecture surrounded by beautiful seas. When we went to Siracusa 10 years ago, a work colleague (Italian) asked his college roommate (from Siracusa) for a restaurant recommendation. He suggested Red Moon Pub and I recommend it heartedly with a caveat - it's a simple, casual locals place in a very large, yurt-like tent with about a dozen tables (the kitchen is in a building right next door). It's not in Ortigia but at the harbor across from the island. Great fresh seafood.
Architecturally, Noto has some great baroque architecture and is an interesting town to wander through (although be prepared for climbing as it's built on a hill).
Each town could easily occupy a day by itself.
Thanks JMN57 and others in this thread for all the great advice. Following up from my question way back in February, wanted to share our experience. We had four nights in Catania, did two day trips around Mt. Etna (one hike, one wine tasting), but then had one day trip south, focusing on Ortigia. Probably one of the best decisions of our trip and could absolutely envision spending a couple days there and in Siracusa. We got a late start so just parked at Parcheggio Gelone (super convenient) and walked a little extra onto the island. Ortigia was even more beautiful than I expected. We saw the Tempio di Apollo, Cathedral and Castello Maniace. Had lunch at Ortigia Fish Bar (highly recommended!) and pistachio cannoli at Amandorla Marciante (divine!). Really loved walking around the island, taking in the sights and enjoying the atmosphere.
Otherwise we also really enjoyed our time in Catania, had several great dinners, enjoyed a city historical walk and the fish market. Really vibrant and energetic city. Look forward to taking more time and exploring more of Sicily during our next trip.