Originally Posted by
Blumie
It also can differ depending on whether you are searching on the website or the app. I've been looking to travel to Nairobi this summer, and have been experiencing wildly different fares depending on mu choice of departure city. I finally found that FLL was one of the cheapest -- if not the cheapest -- departure city, with a J fare of around $4,400. But then I discovered that if I depart from BOS and return to FLL, I could get the fare to drop to $4,050. I'm pretty sure I searched that on AA's website, but now I can only get that fare if I search it on the app. On the website it's now $5,601. Right now, as I type this, I'm coming up with the exact same flights -- BOS-JFK-DOH-NB0-DOH-JFK-CLT-FLL -- to price out in J at $4,050 on the app and $5,601 on the website.
Have you tried searching on the website in an incognito browser?