Originally Posted by
VegasGambler
I agree with the rest of your post, but if stuck in a true E+ seat I would take any Airbus over any Boeing for the extra inch of seat width, regardless of the carrier. So AA from LAX or PHX (ok, not quite west coast) is a good option.
Good point. It would be a close call for me AA vs. AS in Y.
We flew the AA 321 OGG-PHX just last week due to AS mx. Upgraded right after purchase a couple hours prior to departure on a $270 OW fare. It's now a very easy upgrade since AA dropped the widebodies. Interesting to see how discerning the market has become - AA was selling out the F cabin at $2k + RT when they were flying the widebodies, now the F seats are mostly going for upgrades.
AA provided a pillow and a real blanket in F for the redeye.