Originally Posted by
seacarl
While I once assumed that the reason for the cutoff is that AS adjusts the catering for the flight based on the preorders, it doesn't. The number of entrees is fixed, and once the preorder limit is reached it becomes unavailable for preordering. I believe that the preorder limit is less than number of each item boarded, so they may still be available on board. So it could be that they will board 6-6-4 items and limit preorders to 4-4-3 or something similar.
This is no longer true. You can pre-order any of the menu offerings up to 20 hours prior to departure and the request should be honored.