I just had clients do Trisara, then Ritz Phulay Bay and finishing at Amanpuri.
Amanpuri was their favourite (they had a pavilion here without a pool). They really loved Ritz and the area it was in - did a lot of exploring from here. Trisara was their least favourite, but they liked the value here given they had a pool. "Least favourite" came with a disclaimer that it was still fantastic, they just felt the other two were more elevated.