Originally Posted by
simonl98
Thanks for the advice! I guess I'll go with AAdvantage. I live in Columbus right now and AS only operate a daily SEA-CMH flight. There's no reason for me to go to settle frequently so AA should be a better option for me.
Obviously you should take whichever flights are most convenient to you. The real question is where to credit them. If you could still achieve and maintain AS status using partner travel, AS would be a reasonable option (since AS and AA have some reciprocal status benefits). But since you can't, unless you will meet the AS metal segment requirement you are probably better off crediting to AA.