I have a question for you guys..

I have done searches on the hotels above but didn't get a good sense of how they compare.

I will be in NYC Nov 14-19. I got a club room at the Sheraton NY Tower for 279. This is also the same price Westin Times Square is charging me for a regular room.

My client location is at 42nd and Madison. Which hotel is best suited for me?
I'm looking for things like
- location relative to restaurants, things to do, my client, subway
- amenities like gym, hotel food
- room sizes

Should I even consider dumping my club floor room at the Sheraton for the regular room at the Westin?