That is news to me as I just spoke with an agent last week and was told one and one. Also that goes with what I have been previously told as well. I have flown with my dog on AS numerous times. She has enough miles for MVP status . Five seems high by any standard as you then need to allow basically all certified service animals as well. Can you provide a link where you see FIVE in coach. Usually when traveling with the dog I do pay for F but I have traveled in the main cabin with her as well and was told the same. I have even been denied travel on a specific flight as I was told an animal was already reserved. Thanks in advance.