Originally Posted by
rucksack
It sounds like you may have talked to someone in Reservations? You may try calling either Customer Service (800-882-8880) or the Executive Liaison desk (888-747-1427). I've found the latter is particularly able to bend rules.
It wasn't Reservations, but your post inspired me to poke the bear a few more times. After some crazy back and forth, I finally received a Trip Voucher from all of my Flight Vouchers. Amazing. Got lots of flying to do in the next year. Thanks for the reply, good to know about the liason desk #.