If you use the equinox membership it’s a no-brainer, particularly for this year since you easily get benefits that exceed the annual fee:

special travel credit on renewal (this year only) $2,000
equinox membership $3,000
saks annual credit $1,000
Uber annual credit $200
paypal 6 month credit $180
hertz
delta
clear

if you don’t (or can’t) use the equinox membership it comes down to how much you value hertz and delta in my view.