I find it rather telling that you feel the need to make a comment about my post, whereas you do not seem to have a problem with alanw's post, which pretty clearly is not in the spirit our host would like to see on Flyertalk.

With regards to the thread starter's proposal, I would think that that is something that is completely up to Randy and his staff, how they would like to handle this. I pretty much agree with what you said about it.