When an airline offers status match, it is simply asking the passenger to transfer his loyalty to the new airline in exchange for some benefits, which is why I asked for silver status (with proof of holding silver status sent as reference.) Why would Emirates not offer me Silver status now so that when I book with them I would already be enjoying the benefits extended to me in exchange for my loyalty? It's a win/win situation for every one (Emirates makes more profits, I enjoy the privileges' extended to me for my business.)

I enjoy my flights with Emirates but there is simply no incentive for me to fly Emirates when I already enjoy business-class treatment at the price of economy class at my current status with the airline I fly. I can simply pay economy class ticket, get business class treatment at airport, upgrade to business class seat at maybe 50% discount after take-off, and just enjoy my flight. Unless I get the silver status prior to my flight there is simply no incentive for me to fly Emirates

They clearly mentioned after completing the requirements mentioned above in the first post, they would review my account again (they simply can not guarantee me silver tier.)