Originally Posted by
gaobest
How do these whitefish salads compare to the whitefish at Once Upon a Bagel?
Good question. I'm trying to remember Dirk's, it's been a while since I've had it. Maybe
chgoeditor can remind us what it's like. I do recall that I liked it very much. For my homemade one, I flake the fish, so there are bigger pieces in the salad. And I add a few more things, like celery. I like mine the best, but it has to start with a good smoked fish. Once Upon A Bagel's tastes great, as does Max and Benny's. My minor gripe with both of them is that the fish is almost whipped or blended, with no chunks.