Now, now, Boomer, I just booked 2 RTs EWR-PBI for $180 each in January. Not cheap, but not too bad. I don't think I'd care to try my luck mid-November to New Years, though.
And Glen, I think you'd be a bit startled to find yourself in PBL (Puerto Cabello, Venezuela) rather than PBI (West Palm Beach, Florida). Bit of an overshoot or a bit short, depending on which direction you're coming from.