It's so very much a matter of personal taste, but we've not been able to find any Caribbean to love. So much of it is geared toward the mass-market cruise ship crowd. SXM seemed to have a nice flavor but we haven't done much there. Did ANC last summer and also found little to love. The Seward glacier boat tour was worthy, and I suspect there are some great adventures lurking not far from civilization, but we didn't get there. YQB at Christmas was just glorious, but it's hard to get to.