12 May 2019 - applied for renewal at one-year mark

22 Sept 2019 - conditional approval (Vermont return address) at 133-day mark

19 Dec 2019 - completed interview on departure from Aruba without appointment

25 Dec 2019 - approval notification (Miami return address)

Interestingly, Aruba was not listed in the email I received with interview on “arrival” locations, but there are multiple signs advertising it at AUA and there were two people ahead of me and one after me in line to do it. I was not asked any questions but gave a new set of fingerprints and a new photo.