Originally Posted by Mordac

To add my 2p, I'd say that the old BA WTP seats are more comfortable than AA's, especially for sleeping. However, AA has better IFE--this isn't a huge consideration for me, as I prefer to bring my own IFE, which is normally reading, but I know some people value it highly.

I wasn't hugely impressed with the meals on AA: in particular, whenever I've flown their W product there was never any meat choices, which I found appalling! (They hadn't just ran out, it wasn't an option at all!) Can definitely second the recommendation of the window bulkhead seats on AA though. If both passengers are normal sized, you can get up while your seatmate stays in place.