After two stays at the St Regis we have never made it off-site to eat. No concerns, simply that on a 5 night beach holiday we like to be very lazy and enjoy wandering to and from dinner from our room. We have found enough variation at the hotel to make this decent enough, if not amazing (we did really like Carolina actually). I also like that taxes and tip are included in the bills, water is free, and i even get (or did, maybe this was SPG) a 15% discount on the bill.