Hey all,

We've got 3 nights coming up in Koh Samui at the end of next week. Currently at the W, but honestly, I've had a real struggle finding any conviction between which property to choose (chose the W because those circular sofas in the water were on my youthful bucket list). I've read some mediocre reviews of the W, some slightly underwhelming reviews of Vana Belle, and likewise with the hard-product at RC (although from when it was just opening, so may not be up-to-date). As a Titanium, I know I don't get breakfast at RC, which I'm taking into account.

It's just my wife and I, looking to hang out and chill for a few days, somewhere pretty spectacular. Nothing too dramatic, and not intending to apply any SNAs or pay for an upgrade (relying on Tit upgrade if I get lucky).

Anyone been to all 3 of these and have a strong conviction on which is best? It's not too late to switch my reservation, and I know I really should have done this work before! I've read all the individual threads, but really looking for some recent experiences across all 3.

Cheers,
JK