I'll second "the mason jar" as its referred to by regulars. Emerils, Wolfgangs, et. all are fine if you want to eat with tourists, but if you want a true dining experience, head east on I-4. Another suggestion that isn't much for atmosphere, but great food for a great price, is Charley's Steakhouse (the original) on Orange Blossom Trail down by the Dollhouse.

If I was in town with a bunch of guys for work, I'd venture out to Charley's. With a nice lady, Maison Jardin.