Originally Posted by
tmiw
My one experience with gift cards and gas stations didn't go well, so I'm fairly hesitant to try again. (It wasn't even a VGC or MGC, just a $25 Amazon GC.) I'm not sure if it was just that one gas station or if they generally don't allow any GC purchases with credit cards here.
YMMV per gas station. Go to another and try there. If they don't accept CC for GC purchases, walk out and go to the next one - no reason to be hesitant, you're not doing anything wrong. I went to several before finding any in my area that allowed it.