Like I say you're entitled to your opinion on what you consider a good seat and I'll defend your right to have one. The fact is I don't consider seats where your feet are in a small box a good seat. Thanks to the design they generally have a smaller seat pitch too. As an example the Apex suite is a very good seat in my opion as it offers aisle access for all passengers and no foot box. Legend has it that this was an F product that they dumbed down a bit to make it more J. On the flipside the Super Diamond, Thompson Vantage XL etc. are not so great for me because of the foot box. The number of seats doesn't really come into it for me except for the availability of purchase/redemptions. YMMV