We (family of 4) stayed four nights at PH last year between Christmas and New Year and really enjoyed it. As a Globalist we all ate breakfast in the restaurant (and no discussion was raised regarding upcharges or extras) daily and my kids loved the hotel dog Mr. Walker (a Labrador you can take for a walk). I liked being ever so slightly removed from the CBD and Melbourne is dead simple to navigate. I wouldn’t think twice about PH vs GH.