Originally Posted by
Qwkynuf
The post that I quoted specifically called out C+ as not really being an upgrade.
Is a C+ middle better than an aisle or window farther back? No, not for most people. But that's not a valid comparison because I'm sure that most people would agree that *no* middle is better than *any* window or aisle. But seat type for seat type, saying that C+ isn't better than any comparable Y seat on the plane is either disingenuous or snobbery.
But the question isn't if it's better---as I said, a C- aisle is "better" than a C- middle. The question is whether it's properly called an "upgrade." I honestly don't really have an opinion on that, but you just keep making the point that C+ is better, and that's just not the argument.