We had originally planned to go to Providencia, Colombia, having read only good things about the island. Long story short, it was horrible (no infrastructure, only poverty and misery) and we flew back to San Andrés. That wasn’t much better though, all somewhat decent hotels were fully booked. So we ended up flying to Bogotá, hoping we’ll be able to go somewhere NICE tomorrow.

I’m traveling with my in-laws for the first time and they’re not happy (neither am I).
Any suggestions where we could go?

I’m thinking a nice, luxurious beach resort. Ideally bookable on points (Marriott/Hyatt/Hilton/IHG).
Any suggestions?