FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Risk of buying $1 DVDs in China?
View Single Post
Old Jul 29, 2004 | 4:39 pm
  #11  
themicah
All eyes on you!
20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: NYC
Posts: 8,681
Originally Posted by fastflyer
The work product of artists -- whether painters or actors or musicians or novelists -- should not be stolen simply because thieves have thought up new methods of stealing.
"Intellectual Property" is a very new concept and is not the same as Property. We invented a system for rewarding creativity that was abstractly designed to resemble physical property law. But it's not the same thing, because when you copy a movie you are making a copy, not stealing the original.

I agree that Intellectual Property has value and shouldn't be abolished entirely. But new technology calls for new ways of thinking about the world. When VCRs first hit the market, Hollywood threw a tantrum and tried to make them illegal. The Supreme Court had to stand up and say they were okay. Today Hollywood makes a fortune off of DVDs and VHS that wouldn't exist if their idea of what was "theirs" to control had prevailed.

Art adapts. The world adapts. And if senators' campaign contributions came from the artists instead of the distributors, we wouldn't have laws like the Mickey Mouse Protection Act, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, or the proposed Inducing Infringement Act.

Again, I don't advocate theft (and I especially discourage wasting your money on bootleg DVDs). But I do advocate thinking about these issues before making conclusions about them.
themicah is offline