Firebird2k6

Hi all.

I'm really debating about the following and am torn. Risk/Reward situation. Looking for advice:

1.) 4 nights at the JW Cancun club 91 lounge with $100/night credits
2.) 5 nights at the Westin Cozumel all inclusive package. Price is similar to the JW after the credits ($100 more total for extra night [after credits] plus maybe $100 round trip transportation to Cozumel from Cancun airport)

We plan on using the spa a few times.

My conundrums:

The JW has great pools, a great beach, the service isn't a risk, but you only get drinks 6pm-10pm. Service is important. You know the beach is great. Hotel is well kept.

Westin is all inclusive at the restaurants for breakfast, lunch, and dinner and appears you can chose between 3 for dinner. Seems to be lightly frequented, probably high chance of Platinum Premier upgrade, but service reviews have been pretty poor, I've only seen one review of the all inclusive (my biggest concern), the beach is minimal but you can snorkel right off property, the mini-bar is part of the all-inclusive and refreshed daily. I'm thinking the all inclusive offering is new, but it's weird there have been almost no posts about it. If everything they're advertising is awesome, it'll definitely be better bang-for-the-buck. They also haven't updated their official photo from CGI. Will lose 3 hours each way traveling between Cozumel and Cancun airport (hence extra day)

Really torn between these.

Westin: