Followup to this: I had a conversation with an AMEX rep (via chat so there's a written record of it) where I was told that this property does count towards the $250 credit. But, yes, it's closing soon--end of January 2019 now.
Originally Posted by
Adam1222
The only property that folks have reported as triggering the credit that is not on the list is in Waikiki. The search function you are discussing is irrelevant, as it is both overinclusive and underinclusive with the list of qualifying hotels.
Others have suggested there may be other properties, but refuse to provide specifics. But even if individuals have had luck in the past, I would not assume that any property that is not on the list of eligible properties would trigger the credit.
(Also note this particular property is closing is closing in 10 days.)