Originally Posted by
Adam Smith
It's quite clear that we have very different preferences... Although I'd be curious what you'd think of one I recently bought that's very sherried (?) and zero peat, but 66.7% alcohol.
I think I just have a broader range? Or maybe yours are more refined? Either way, it's not an insult to me as I will take some credit (regardless if you give any credit

) for your Scotch knowledge and preferences.
Originally Posted by
Adam Smith
Although I'd be curious what you'd think of one I recently bought that's very sherried (?) and zero peat, but 66.7% alcohol.
I'm totally open to this. Peat or no peat. Sherry Cask or no Sherry Cask.