Originally Posted by
samwise6222
They actually felt pretty nice.
One problem with AA is when the person ahead of you reclines all the way, it kinda feels cramped. (even though you have much more space than Y)
Exactly, I have flown the much maligned AF fixed shell seats. I did have to use my pillow for back support, but it was nice that the seat in front of you cannot move, and no one gives that enough credit. When I flew AA PE the person in front of me decided to take advantage of the generous recline on a daytime flight the moment we get in the air for the entire flight, so things felt a lot more cramped pretty quickly.