Just to make things more confusing, here is a vote for the Renaissance. The Ren treats plats very well and the last 4 times I stayed here I got upgraded to a big river view corner suite. Breakfast can be had at the lounge or the restaurant, the latter being the better option.
The gym is large, clean and features newer equipment. The lounge gets crowded in the evening and the offerings are average. Service overall is very good and the price is hard to beat.