I'm considering this hotel for our anniversary vacation in late Oct or early Nov (this year) and overall it sounds great. Just had a question that I can't find the answer to in this thread:

One non-negotiable requirement for my wife when we travel is that the room have a deep "soaking" tub rather than a standard tub or tub/shower combo. From some pictures online it appears that all rooms have the rainshower and also what appears to be a deep, though small-ish tub in the room. Is this accurate and if so, is the tub at least large enough to be useful? I did note that the suites have a separate free standing tub which would be fine but don't know if that upgrade will be available (using Amex FHR) and can't take the chance that the regular Ocean View rooms don't have a decent one.

Actually the old Renaissance Wailea was one of our favorites before it closed. We used to stay in the Mokapu suites (which were really just modest hotel rooms on just off the beach) and loved the ability to have a short walk to the beach, use the "private pool" etc. Many of the staff were long term as well which resulted in a nice vibe.

Thanks to all!

I'm planning to use Amex FHR for 5th night free and the other benefits it offers. Any better deals anywhere? I don't have any other cards with significant benefits and down to 150,000 points or so with Starwood/Marriott. Thanks again!