Wasn't sure whether to post this on the BA or AA forums, but here goes! We're thinking of having a few days in NYC and I'm trying to weigh up the Economy v Business Class fares and products. As far as I can see, choosing BA metal seems to run the risk of a 747 that has not been refurbished so I thought I might take the opportunity of trying AA.

With my BAEC Silver, does anyone know whether I would be able to select the AA Economy 'Main Cabin Extra' seat free of charge? It seems that the equivalent AA Platinum passenger can, but I think some schemes have odd rules when it comes to seat selection.

I've searched and can't find anything conclusive. Any first hand experience would be appreciated.