Originally Posted by
mats184
Indeed. But how do you know the person sitting in an exit row seat does not experience back issues or is unable to perform his duties during an emergency? To be frank: why wouldn't the crew in that case just sit by the door ready to react to an emergency? Maybe during meal hours or providing a blanket/pillow in the overhead bin a cabin crew would injure his/her back?
If the person cannot get his suitcase from the overhead bin than it is promoting safety during an emergency evacuation, I would argue, as they would think, no it's too high up or heavy
But of course, people are required by law to follow instructions by crew and should not behave in a manner that compromise safety of the work place or the job satisfaction of the crew.
Because the crew specifically asks them if they feel it will be a problem if they have to and well, if they lie, they are putting their lives and everyone else's at risk.
Your reasoning suggests you don't take the 0,0000001% chance of something happening seriously.
If ever you sit next to me and your luggage isn't fully under the seat in front of you and the FA doesn't notice, I'll tell you to put it in correctly and will escalate to the FA if you don't. I take that chance very seriously and will not want to stumble on your bag getting out of the plane.
I'll also gladly assist you in getting out in case of an emergency, or putting your luggage in the overhead bin if it's too heavy for you.