Originally Posted by
JBord
This sounds about right. I understand it's the reason Achatz's Next here in Chicago will never get a star. Because he completely revamps the theme, menu, concept, and even the decor every few months, there's no way to judge the consistency factor. Not sure if that's 100% true, but it's what I've heard from those in the industry.
This is true - the format of Next having 3 different menus a year doesn't fit the Michelin "model". I love the variety it offers.
Regarding the questions about Alinea - yes, I would go back. But I can only afford that level of meal every so often, and there are still many other places I want to try! The food tasted great, although there were a couple misses for me, as I expect there would be for everyone given personal tastes.
Lastly, a totally unrelated question. I am spending a week in London and Paris in September, and looking to hit one 2-3* place total. Any recommendations given that the plan is to only go to one? I'd imagine Paris is probably better but I'm looking for expert opinion here!